Conversation

Someone introduces themselves as nonbinary. Do you intuitively, at a gut level, view them as neither male nor female, or does your brain process them as their apparent birth gender? (this is regardless of how you treat them, if you use pronouns, etc.)

Neither male/female
3.8%
It varies a lot
19.3%
Typically birth gender
76.8%

2,973 votesFinal results

Replying to

Why do you assume that their apparent gender is the same as their birth gender?

Peasant-Elect, Pay Tree Arch

Replying to

and

She said "apparent birth gender" - as in, if you had to guess what gender they were assigned at birth. Your guess may not be right, but a perfectly androgynous person is very rare. Most people present more traits of one gender than the other, due to either biology or preference.

Replying to

and

“Most people present more traits of one gender than the other”, yes, but not necessarily more of their birth gender. Apparent gender is basically clothes, hairstyle and facial hair. Shaven, most people could pass for any gender if they wished.

Replying to

and

I... don't think this is true? I think likely I could guess what genitals someone has with like 95% accuracy regardless of their hair or clothing (maybe less so with makeup)

7:31 PM · May 17, 2020

Replying to

and

(I forgot about bosom; let's assume it's flat.) You are certainly right. But the remaining 5% are probably mostly made of the people who identify as non-binary.

Replying to

and

I... don't know about that? I am extremely confident about the assigned-at-birth gender of nearly every nonbinary person I've met. Like it just seems extremely obvious to me.

Show replies

Replying to

and

I'm a cis woman, I don't wear makeup, I shop in the women's section, I'm curvy, I don't have PCOS, and I've spent my adult life getting called "sir", asked if I'm a boy or a girl, and having people think I'm in the wrong restroom. I think you might be surprised.

Replying to

and

I mean, getting 95% of people’s birth gender right is super easy, the vast majority of people are cisgender, 95% would be a bad score. I seriously doubt that you can get 95% accuracy looking at a group made of 50% trans people and 50% cis, not without very close observation.