A Busted Posey

Possible he wanted to get something special and different. He just chose poorly

at BEST it indicates a complete lack of understanding of/respect for her preferences combined with utter stupidity

They symbolize so much to some people and he pretty much wiped his ass with the idea of it all. I’d be blindsided and stunned too

Yeah except many guys don't know what style is for jewelry. I have many things where I have preferences and would never expect somebody to know how to duplicate my likes

Right he didn’t even try. He asked for help from no one. I made more of an effort assembling a hamper tonight

My mom, all my friends, many of my friends' partners, and at least one of his besties all have a ballpark of what I want should he just say "what would she like" if I hadn't already shown him exactly what I will and will not like

I have a group of friends who got engaged within a few years of each other and share a jeweler. No one would let happen. I assume she wanted an engagement ring and not something from a craft show?

I would never think to ask somebody else because why the hell would anybody know